Part Two
The Method
pages 29 to 44 start 2:15 am end 3:15 am 4/3/12
Chapter 3 Reading for life
The chapter discusses the torture of staff meetings because of the endless hours of ‘Why Juan Can’t Read and how to fix it.’ The school has not made AYP and has literacy coaches. Page 31 has a list of reasons why Johnny can’t read that all lay within the realm of adults:
Powerful forces of mediocrity have combined to prevent perfectly competent children from learning to love reading. These forces include television, video games, poor teaching, poverty, the breakup of the family, and general lack of adult guidance.
I agree that these are the forces that have an affect. But there are so many more that take place that lie in the realm of the child, the most important one is the unwillingness to want to try. As a teacher I can teach, show, introduce my students to the joys of reading but they have to want to try. The author also states that the curriculum is such that demands that we teach the same skills to the whole class at the same time. My problem with this is that in all my years of education as a student, I can not remember ever having direct skill instruction in reading. I must have been in reading groups and must have had instruction but I can not remember it. What I do remember is the reading that I did outside of the classroom. This is the reading that I remember.
page 32 A Different Focus = This goes back to my previous statement. The reading I remember is the books I read outside of the classroom, the grocery sacks (yes sacks it was always 2) that I would check out of the book mobile, the public library. The most frustrating thing for me was that no matter what library it was I was limited to the number of books I could read. I had the joy of reading.
page 33 The Adult as a Guide I wish that I could do this. My 7th grade students in Texas learned to love to read because I was able to give them classic literature repeatedly. I did not have to use the text and when I did it was as if someone turned off the magic in the room. We had book talks and studies. Rafe, the author, teaches like this.
page 37 Choosing LIterature= Book lists, yep I could get into that.
page 39 = Students who can not read= On level material, constant explanation, written work in class, student selected books at their level. Everything listed is used in my class except for the last one, time comes into play. When can I give them the reading time and teach wh at I am told to teach. If I could do it all then the magic of reading would happen. This is why I look forward to after MSA. I can/could teach like I know how to and do what works. That is not happening this year.
page 40 Middle and High School Teachers= Not sure why this is here except to say that there are so many books on content areas that those teachers should teach reading also.
Page 41 Assessment = www.novelties.com has so many books with questions already created.
Page 41 Making Things Relevant= Rafe states that when children read for pleasure then they learn about the world around them. I so agree. He brings in that plays are available to go see, movies are available also. That leads into what I hear from my students and adults around me :Why read when I can go see the movie?” Ok just yesterday my daughter went to the movie The Hunger Games. After I picked her up she discussed the movie. Her first statement surprised me that this movie was a better adaptation than Harry Potter. I do believe her because not only has she read all of Harry Potter several times and seen the movies but she has also read the Hunger Games books and now the movie. She compared and contrasted the movie with the book.
Page 43 Laughter and Tears = What is the goal of reading? Making lifelong readers that make a connection to the real world and the understand what the magic of reading is.
Ok what does all this mean? It means that the way that we teach reading is not doing its job. Isolated skills is not making these children want to read. This is my problem in that how do I make them learn to read and make them enjoy it and teach them English at the same time. The last few months after testing is when I did that. That is not going to happen now.